Review: “Letters for Scarlet” by Julie C. Gardner

2 Apr

Letters for Scarlet cover

I thank Julie C. Gardner and Velvet Morning Press for the opportunity to review this fine debut novel.

My Review

Epistolary novels–novels in which the narrative is entrusted to letters between characters–have long fascinated me. Ever since I read Clarissa by Samuel Richardson (or parts of it–it is very long), I have thought of this 18th-century masterpiece as the quintessential example of the form.  Despite its length, it is exquisitely suspenseful because the author has such ingenious control over disclosure of the facts and the secrets, little by little.  This feature should make the form attractive to authors of any era, but how does one go about writing an epistolary novel today? How does one craft a story through letters that feels both contemporary and natural?

In her new novel, Letters for Scarlet, Julie C. Gardner has figured out how do this beautifully by adopting a hybrid technique. The story unfolds through narrative and dialogue that we expect to find in a novel, but the main revelations that bind the story together and illuminate its characters’ motives occur in the abundant letters inserted throughout. Gardner handles both ways of telling her story with sureness of purpose and a very genuine voice. Or, should I say, “voices,” because the letters require her to speak in many voices.  But nearly all the letters are intended for the same recipient, Scarlet Hinden, one of the novel’s two pivotal characters. Most of the letters are from her friend Corie Harper.

Both Corie and Scarlet are 28. Corie is an English teacher and aspiring writer, married to Tuck Slater. They would like to have children but so far have been frustrated by trying, something that deeply wounds Corie who already has some nagging doubts about her marriage. Scarlet is a busy attorney and in a relationship with Gavin; she is expecting a baby but struggling with paralyzing fears about being a mother; she is skeptical of ever finding happiness and holding on to it.  What is the connection between these two couples, and how is it influencing their pain in the present moment?

Corie and Scarlet were inseparable friends in high school, and along with Tuck, they were a solid trio until something happened that destroyed the women’s friendship and upended all their lives. We know that the trio turned into a triangle when Corie and Tuck became a couple, but clearly much more must have transpired to cause the kind of unbridgeable rift they are suffering.  It doesn’t seem like anything will change their situation, until Corie receives a letter from the past: the letter she wrote 10 years ago to her future self. It was an assignment in her senior English class (and a very clever mechanism to introduce the first letters into the story). Since she wrote it before her friendship with Scarlet fell apart, Corie feels the loss even more acutely, the aching absence of something that was once unquestionable.  Corie begins to write a series of letters to Scarlet, ones she thinks she’ll never dare send, but which allow her to open her heart to the friend she still needs so desperately. Here are a few bits of her first letter:

Did you get your ten-year letter  from Mr. Roosevelt? Until Tuck handed me that envelope, I had completely forgotten about the assignment. But since I read those words from the past, I’ve been prompted by a desire (more like a need) to say a few things to you. Some old. Some new. All of them true. For what it’s worth. …

I’m sorry we didn’t tell you about us sooner. I suppose the secrets we keep can be as dangerous as the ones we share. Maybe more so.

Sometimes I wonder how different our lives would be if the three of us had loved each other less….

In a surprising move, Scarlet’s mother visits Corie and entrusts her with Scarlet’s 10-year letter.  Corie wants to deliver this powderkeg letter but she hesitates, since Scarlet has refused all contact since high school.

I read the last two thirds of this novel in one long sitting–it was that compelling and I didn’t want to stop until I discovered what tragedy drove these friends apart and how–or whether–they could move on from it. This fine debut novel convincingly explores the ties of love and friendship at the breaking point.


Pain can take a lifetime to heal, but hope lasts even longer…

Corie Harper is twenty-eight years old when she is first visited by a ghost—in the form of a graduation letter she forgot she wrote. Although she spent a decade burying that desperate girl and her regrets, each page resurrects the past, dragging Corie back to a time when all she craved was Scarlet Hinden’s friendship and Tuck Slater’s heart. But she couldn’t keep them both and keep her word.

Scarlet is haunted in her own way, by memories of Corie and of a night that left her wishing she were dead. But Scarlet is not only alive, she’s carrying new life: a baby she never wanted and is terrified to have. Convinced she would be a disastrous mother, she questions whether or not she deserves the love of any man. Especially the father of her child.

Letters for Scarlet traces one friendship from deep roots to branches torn by broken promises and loss.

Release date: April 4, 2016

Publisher: Velvet Morning Press

Buy the book: Amazon

About Julie C. Gardner

Julie C Gardner, author photoI’m a former English teacher and lapsed marathon runner who traded in the classroom for a writing nook. I am the co-author of You Have Lipstick on Your Teeth, and a contributor to the upcoming anthology So Glad They Told Me; my essays have appeared in BlogHerVoices of the Year: 2012 and Precipice Literary Anthology. I live in Southern California with my husband, two children, and three dogs.

Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Website | Blog



*Note*: I received an advance electronic copy of this book, in exchange for an honest review.  I did not receive any other compensation, and the views expressed in my review are my own opinions.

8 Responses to “Review: “Letters for Scarlet” by Julie C. Gardner”

  1. Faith Hope & Cherrytea April 2, 2016 at 8:41 am #

    Well done, Lucy – I’m intrigued, thanks to your review. A modern day epistolary I loved reading is Katherine Reay’s Dear Mr Knightley.
    Thanks for reading and posting – I’ll be adding to my TBR list.

    • Lucy Pollard-Gott April 11, 2016 at 10:16 pm #

      Thanks, Sharon! I appreciate the recommendation of Dear Mr. Knightley.

  2. juliecgardner April 2, 2016 at 12:40 pm #

    Lucy, thank you very much for this beautiful review. Your thoughtful, detailed insights (with both themes and character) are exactly what I was hoping a reader might take away from the story.

    • Lucy Pollard-Gott April 11, 2016 at 10:21 pm #

      Thank you, Julie, for your thoughtful and compelling story, and for your very kind reception of my thoughts about it. It was a pleasure to write about this super debut!

  3. Katie April 2, 2016 at 5:00 pm #

    What a great review! I can’t wait to read this book.

    • Lucy Pollard-Gott April 11, 2016 at 10:23 pm #

      Thanks, Katie! I’m eager to read your series!

      • Katie April 28, 2016 at 9:08 pm #

        Why thank you, Lucy!

  4. Isi May 18, 2016 at 2:39 pm #

    Hi Lucy! I also read this one (I still have to post my review).
    I liked the theme, about the lost friendship between the women, and the way it is written, narration mixed with the letters to Scarlet.
    However, what I didn’t like that much were the “problems” the protagonists fight against (not having children, being afraid of compromise), because I feel I read about the same issues in every “women’s fiction” book I’ve read.
    It’s my perception; perhaps I should read other genres more often, in order not to get tired of the topics I mentioned.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Swimming the Depths

We Are All Called to Lives of Holiness

Dominican Nuns

Dominican Monastery of St. Jude, Marbury, Alabama

Children of God for Life

Pro-Life Leader in Campaign for Ethical Research

Rosary to the Interior: For the Purification of the Church

"The once holy and always in need of purification, follows constantly the path of penance and renewal.”—Lumen Gentium 8

Clarifying Catholicism

Just another WordPress site


An esoteric and enigmatic journey towards Catholicism

Illumina Domine Blog - Devotion to The Holy Face

Devotion to the Holy Face of Jesus - to make Him known and loved.

Chris Werms

Theology for the West Suburbs of Chicago

EWTN Bookmark Brief

Enjoy this short videoblog, featuring some of our favorite authors and their most recent works.

Pure Glory

The heavens are telling the glory of God; and the firmament proclaims His handiwork. Psalms 19:1

Entering the Enchanted Castle

A quest for the magic in life, language, and literature

Rev. Rebecca Writes

Faith. Books. Disability Awareness

Faith Hope & Cherrytea

inspiring and inspiriting ...

Myrtle Skete

Orthodox Gleanings

Catholicism Pure & Simple

Catholicism without compromise

Joan's Rome

by EWTN's Rome Bureau Chief Joan Lewis

Burning Hearts

A personal journey into sacred scripture

Living Our Days

Gaining a heart of wisdom


Book reviews by someone who loves books ...

Third Order Carmelites TOC

Ordo Fratrum Beatissimæ Virginis Mariæ de Monte Carmelo

%d bloggers like this: